Young InnovatorsFOR CHANGEinnovateyouth.org

Teacher Guide

Where Did It Go? · Grade 4 science · 36 weeks

Answers, the point of each week, and the specific wrong turn each one produces. Written for a teacher who is not a science specialist and does not need to become one.

Every table of results in the book is practice data, invented so the whole class can answer the same questions, and the page says so every time. When your class does the real investigation its numbers will differ. Ask which numbers are more trustworthy, theirs or the book’s. The answer is theirs, because they watched it happen.

The book never says energy is used up, and it helps if nobody in the room does either. Energy moves and changes form. A ball that stops bouncing did not run out of energy; its energy became sound and warmth. Holding that line all year is most of what the year is for.

No page asks a child what happened to them in an earthquake. Week 26 teaches Drop, Cover, Hold On and keeps to what people can do. A child who has felt a strong earthquake may want to talk about it, and should be the one who decides to.

verify.py, which ships beside this file and runs on every build, checks all 129 answers below: every number is recomputed from the practice data as printed in the workbook, and every worded answer is checked against its expected wording. It also checks that every table a page calls a fair test changes exactly one thing.

EnergyTransferLandscapes WavesSensesTopics Materials and safety
Part 1 · Weeks 1 to 7

Speed, collisions and energy

Something moving has energy, and the faster it moves, the more. Speed is distance divided by time. In a collision the energy moves on, and some of it becomes sound and warmth. Weeks 5 and 6 are the first design problem: a lander, a measured dent, and one change at a time.

Week 1Faster Means More

Energy · sits beside: Speed and energy (4-PS3-1)
The point

Something moving has energy, and the faster it moves the more energy it has. The cup is the measuring instrument.

Answers and marking
Moved the cup farthest4 books
4 books against 1 book26 cm
The higher the ramp, the faster the ball, so the cupmoves farther
Watch for

Students who say the higher ramp has more energy because it is higher. That is true and it is an idea for later grades; this week, keep them on speed at the bottom of the ramp.

Challenge Zone

Change only the ball's weight: same ramp, same height, same cup. A good answer names at least two things kept the same.

Week 2Speed You Can Measure

Energy · sits beside: Speed and energy (4-PS3-1)
The point

Speed is distance divided by time, and a measured speed lets a student say how much more energy, not just more.

Answers and marking
Car A speed20 cm each second
Car B speed30 cm each second
Car C speed15 cm each second
Car D speed40 cm each second
Car E speed30 cm each second
The fastest carD
The two at the same speedB and E
The most energyD
Watch for

Students who rank the cars by distance. Car E went less far than car B and has the same speed, which is the reason the table includes it.

Challenge Zone

Car E took 4 seconds instead of 5. Each second it went 30 cm, the same as car B, which simply kept going one second longer.

Week 3When Things Collide

Energy · sits beside: Energy in collisions (4-PS3-3)
The point

In a collision, energy moves from one object to the other. The marble that stops did not lose its energy; it passed it on.

Answers and marking
2 books against 1 bookabout 2 times
3 books against 2 books21 cm
Where the first marble's energy wentinto the second marble
Watch for

Students who say the first marble ran out of energy. Ask where it went, and point at the marble that is now rolling.

Challenge Zone

The marble at the far end rolls away and the middle ones barely move. The energy traveled through the line of marbles, which is the whole idea.

Week 4Where the Energy Went

Energy · sits beside: Energy in collisions (4-PS3-3)
The point

A ball bounces lower each time because some of its energy becomes sound and warmth at every bounce; the squashing springs back. It is shared out, not used up.

Answers and marking
Bounce 1 against bounce 220 cm
The biggest dropbounces 1 and 2
Two places the energy wentsound and warmth
Watch for

The phrase “the ball ran out of energy.” Correct it every time, kindly: the energy went into sound and warmth, and there was not enough left to lift it.

Challenge Zone

About 13 cm, seven tenths of 19. It stops because every bounce turns more of its energy into sound and warmth, until none is left to lift it off the floor. The energy is all still there, as sound and warmth.

Week 5Protect the Egg

Design · sits beside: Testing and improving a design (3-5-ETS1-3)
The point

Criteria and constraints first, then a prototype built to be tested. The clay dent turns a landing into a measurement.

Answers and marking
Meets the criterion and every constraintstraw cage
Protected best but broke a constraintcotton balls
Straw cage against no protection4 mm
Watch for

Students who pick cotton balls because the dent was smallest. The rules said paper and straws only.

Challenge Zone

Any design that spreads the landing out: a crumple zone, a spring, legs that bend. The good answer says the lander, not the clay, should take in the energy.

Week 6Test, Change, Test Again

Design · sits beside: Testing and improving a design (3-5-ETS1-3)
The point

Change one thing, test again. A change that makes no difference is a finding, not a failure.

Answers and marking
The change that made no differencepainted it red
The change that helped mostadded a paper spring
Why one change at a timeso you know which change caused the result
Watch for

Students who think painting it red helped because the dent did not get worse. No change in the result is the answer.

Challenge Zone

Any single change with a way to measure it. The requirement is one change and the same drop.

Week 7Energy Moves

Review · sits beside: Speed and energy (4-PS3-1)
The point

Faster means more energy, and in a collision it moves on. Part 1 in a bowling lane.

Answers and marking
The fastest ball knocked down the mostyes
Fastest against slowest7
Least energy to mostD, A, C, B
Watch for

Students who say ball D had no energy. It was moving, so it had some; not enough to knock a pin over.

Challenge Zone

No. It was moving, so it had energy; it just did not have enough to tip a pin. A strong answer adds that its energy went into rolling and sound.

Part 2 · Weeks 8 to 15

Energy on the move, and where it comes from

Energy transfers as motion, sound, light, heat and electric current. A circuit is a closed loop. Devices convert energy from one form to another, and students design one. Every source of energy starts in the natural world, and every source costs something.

Week 8Energy Travels

Transfer · sits beside: Energy moving from place to place (4-PS3-2)
The point

Energy can cross a room as sound, with nothing solid carrying it, and it can still move something when it arrives.

Answers and marking
Farthest that still made rice jump80 cm
20 cm against 60 cm9
The farther the panthe fewer grains jump
Watch for

Students who answer 100 cm because it is the farthest in the table. At 100 cm no grains jumped.

Challenge Zone

More grains jump. Tapping harder gives the sound more energy, so it can still shake the wrap from farther away.

Week 9Light, Sound, Heat, Current

Transfer · sits beside: Energy moving from place to place (4-PS3-2)
The point

Energy travels as motion, sound, light, heat and electric current, and dark materials take in more of the light that reaches them.

Answers and marking
Row alight
Row bsound
Row celectric current
Row dheat
Row elight
Row fheat
The only sound rowb
How many light rows2
Warmed the mostblack paper
Black paper against white paper16°
Why white roofswhite takes in less of the light, so it stays cooler
Watch for

Students who call row a heat because the sidewalk got warm. Ask how the energy got from the sun to the sidewalk: there is nothing in between but light.

Challenge Zone

Row c arrives as current and becomes light at the lamp; row d arrives as heat and warms the hands. Any row with both forms named is right.

Week 10A Closed Loop

Transfer · sits beside: Energy moving from place to place (4-PS3-2)
The point

Current flows only around a closed loop, and only through some materials.

Answers and marking
How many let the current through3
What they have in commonthey are all metal
Why wires are covered in plasticcurrent cannot flow through plastic, so the wire is safe to touch
Watch for

Students tempted to try a wall outlet or to wire the battery to itself. The page says never, twice; say it again before the first wire is touched.

Challenge Zone

Two bulbs in one loop, one after the other: take one out and the loop opens, so both go dark. Two bulbs each on their own loop from the battery: take one out and the other stays lit. Accept any drawing with clearly closed loops. With one AA battery, two bulbs in one loop may only glow dimly.

Week 11Changing the Form

Converting · sits beside: Converting energy (4-PS3-4)
The point

Energy changes form, and devices are built to change it on purpose.

Answers and marking
Seconds per extra minuteabout 4 seconds
Prediction for 25 minutesabout 100 seconds
Every form the energy tooklight, then electric energy stored in the toy, then motion
Watch for

Students who multiply 25 by 79. Ask what one minute of sun gives first.

Challenge Zone

No: the toy's battery fills up, so after a while more sun stops adding running time. Any limit with a reason is a good answer.

Week 12Build a Converter

Converting · sits beside: Designing a device that converts energy (4-PS3-4)
The point

A converter can be designed and improved, and more of something is not always better.

Answers and marking
Fastest lift6 blades
How many met the criterion3
Where more blades stopped helpingafter 6 blades
Watch for

Students who think 2 blades is fastest because 18 is the biggest number. Fewer seconds is faster.

Challenge Zone

Any single change, tested the same way. A strong answer predicts before testing.

Week 13Where Fuel Comes From

Sources · sits beside: Energy from natural resources (4-ESS3-1)
The point

Every source of energy starts in the natural world, and some are replaced quickly while others take millions of years.

Answers and marking
Fraction renewable6/10
The biggest single sourcenatural gas
More parts needed for 8 out of 102
Watch for

Students who count natural gas as renewable because it comes from plants. It took millions of years to form; once burned, it is gone.

Challenge Zone

Store energy in batteries, use wind or water at night, or keep some other source ready. Any workable plan is right.

Week 14Every Source Costs Something

Sources · sits beside: Energy from natural resources (4-ESS3-1)
The point

Every energy source has costs, and choosing one means choosing which costs to accept.

Answers and marking
Lowest air pollutionPlan C: more wind
Least landPlan A: more gas
Both scores 5 or lessPlan D: half gas, half solar
Watch for

Students who choose plan C because it has the best single number. The town's rule needs both scores at 5 or less.

Challenge Zone

Two for and two against, each tied to a number. The point is that both sides can be argued honestly.

Week 15Follow the Energy

Review · sits beside: Energy moving from place to place (4-PS3-2)
The point

Every action in Part 2 was a link in a chain of energy moving and changing.

Answers and marking
Chain A links4
Chain B links4
Chain C links5
Chain D links2
The most linksC
The two that begin with a renewable sourceA and C
Watch for

Students who count arrows instead of names. The column asks for names, the first and last included. Some also miss chain A because sunlight does not feel like a source; it is the first renewable source on week 13's list.

Challenge Zone

The sun warms some places more than others; warm air rises and cooler air moves in to take its place. That moving air is wind.

Part 3 · Weeks 16 to 22

Sculpting landscapes

Rock forms in layers, lowest usually oldest, with fossils that record what lived there. Weathering breaks rock and erosion carries it away, faster on steep bare slopes. Mountains, volcanoes and earthquakes make patterns on a map along the edges of the Earth's plates.

Week 16Rock in Layers

Landscapes · sits beside: Rock layers as evidence (4-ESS1-1)
The point

Layers are laid down in order, so the lowest is usually the oldest, and fossils show what lived there.

Answers and marking
The oldest layerD
The two with sea fossilsB and C
The whole wall45 m
Watch for

Students who answer A because it is first in the table. The table runs top to bottom.

Challenge Zone

Gravel at the bottom, sand, then fine soil on top: the heaviest pieces settle fastest.

Week 17Fossils in the Layers

Landscapes · sits beside: Rock layers as evidence (4-ESS1-1)
The point

The same layer on both sides of a valley was once one layer, cut through later.

Answers and marking
Missing from cliff 2leaf layer
Fossil layers both cliffs share2
Watch for

Students who think the river made the layers. It uncovered them. Some will count the soil as a shared layer: it has no fossils, and it formed on each side after the river cut the valley, so it is not a matched layer.

Challenge Zone

Any third cliff that shares two layers and adds one. The good answer places the new layer in time using the shared ones.

Week 18Breaking Rock

Landscapes · sits beside: Weathering and erosion (4-ESS2-1)
The point

Weathering breaks rock where it is. The sugar cube model shows how corners go first.

Answers and marking
The most crumbs broke offbetween 0 and 50 shakes
From 50 shakes to 200 shakes6 g
Watch for

Students who read 10 g for the second question. It asks from 50 shakes, where 4 g had already broken off.

Challenge Zone

Sugar dissolves and most rock does not, so water would be a bad test of this model. It shows rocks grinding against each other well.

Week 19How Fast It Wears Away

Landscapes · sits beside: Weathering and erosion (4-ESS2-1)
The point

Erosion is faster on steep slopes and slower where plants hold the soil.

Answers and marking
Fair test of the surfaceR3 and R5
Fewer spoonfuls with sprouts8
Steeper slopemore
Watch for

Plan ahead: plant grass seed in a second pan of damp sand at least a week before, or there is no sprouted tray to test. Then watch for students who compare R1 with R5. Two things differ there: the slope and the surface.

Challenge Zone

Terraces, a mat of leaves, rocks across the channel. Any idea tested with the same cup of water.

Week 20Patterns on a Map

Landscapes · sits beside: Patterns in Earth's features (4-ESS2-2)
The point

A pattern on a map is evidence, often before anyone can explain it.

Answers and marking
Earthquakes on the map8
Where the dots arealong the coast, just inland of it
Watch for

Students who describe the dots as scattered. Trace the coastline with a finger and they follow it.

Challenge Zone

Any practice map with a question a classmate can answer from it.

Week 21Where Mountains Are

Landscapes · sits beside: Patterns in Earth's features (4-ESS2-2)
The point

Mountains, volcanoes and earthquakes often line up along the edges of the Earth's plates, and California sits on one.

Answers and marking
The tallest peakB
Peaks taller than 2,000 meters3
Tallest against shortest2,170 m
Where the tall peaks arenear the coast
Watch for

Students who compare only the hundreds. Write each height with its comma and compare the thousands first.

Challenge Zone

The plate edge is probably along the coast, because the tall peaks are close to it and the short ones far away. A strong answer says this is a clue, not proof.

Week 22Reading a Landscape

Review · sits beside: Rock layers as evidence (4-ESS1-1)
The point

A landscape is a sequence of events, and you can put them in order.

Answers and marking
Row a2
Row b4
Row c1
Row d3
Happened firstc
Happened lastb
Watch for

Students who put the river first because rivers are old. The layers must exist before anything can cut through them.

Challenge Zone

Anything that happened after the canyon, placed after it.

Part 4 · Weeks 23 to 29

Waves and earthquakes

A wave carries energy without carrying the water. Amplitude and wavelength can be measured, and a taller wave carries more energy. Earthquakes send waves through the ground; Drop, Cover, Hold On; and students design and compare structures that stand through shaking.

Week 23A Wave Moves Energy

Waves · sits beside: Waves carry energy (4-PS4-1)
The point

A wave carries energy across water without carrying the water along.

Answers and marking
Farthest the cork moved1 cm
Did the cork travel with the wavesno
Watch for

Students who expect the cork to arrive at the far end. Let them watch it bob.

Challenge Zone

Each part of the rope moves up and down in place; the bend travels along it, and that is the energy.

Week 24Tall and Long

Waves · sits beside: Waves carry energy (4-PS4-1)
The point

Every wave has an amplitude and a wavelength, and a taller wave carries more energy.

Answers and marking
The greatest amplitudeD
The two with the longest wavelengthC and D
A or B, more energyB
Watch for

Students who mix up the two columns. Point at the drawing: up is amplitude, along is wavelength.

Challenge Zone

Two drawings, same crest spacing, one twice as tall. Check both labels.

Week 25Waves Move Things

Waves · sits beside: Waves carry energy (4-PS4-1)
The point

When a wave reaches something, its energy can push it, and bigger waves push harder.

Answers and marking
4 cm waves against 2 cm waves19 g
The extra sand each centimetergrows
Watch for

Students who say the difference stays the same. 5, then 8, then 11.

Challenge Zone

Storm waves are taller, and the extra sand moved grows faster than the height, so beaches change far more in a storm.

Week 26When the Ground Shakes

Earthquakes · sits beside: Reducing the impact of natural hazards (4-ESS3-2)
The point

An earthquake sends waves through the ground that weaken with distance, and Drop, Cover, Hold On is the first thing to know.

Answers and marking
Weakest shaking80 km
Half as strong as 10 km away20 km
The farther from where it startedthe weaker the shaking
Watch for

Children who have felt a strong earthquake may be anxious. Keep the week on what people can do, and do not ask anyone to describe what happened to them.

Challenge Zone

Any three steps that reduce harm: fasten shelves, know the safe spot, practice the drill.

Week 27Build It to Stand

Earthquakes · sits beside: Reducing the impact of natural hazards (4-ESS3-2)
The point

Wide bases and braced triangles help a structure stand through shaking.

Answers and marking
Meets every criterion and the constraintA
Stood through every shake but broke the constraintC
Watch for

Students who choose D because it stood through every shake. It is only 20 cm tall.

Challenge Zone

Cross braces where they matter most, fewer elsewhere. A drawing and a prediction are the requirement.

Week 28Compare the Designs

Earthquakes · sits beside: Comparing design solutions (3-5-ETS1-2)
The point

Comparing solutions fairly means the same test and the same rules for all of them.

Answers and marking
Meets the criterion and the constraintstrap the shelves to the wall
Kept the most books but broke the constraintuse only low shelves
Shelf lip against straps4
Watch for

Students who choose the lip because it is cheapest. Six books fell.

Challenge Zone

Straps plus lips, for example: about the cost of both, with fewer books falling. Any reasoned combination.

Week 29Shaking, Measured

Review · sits beside: Waves carry energy (4-PS4-1)
The point

Earthquake waves recorded on paper get smaller with distance, in a pattern you can predict.

Answers and marking
Each time the distance doublesit halves
Prediction for 160 km1.5 mm
Watch for

Students who subtract 12 each time. The pattern is halving, not taking away.

Challenge Zone

48 mm, twice the 10 km wiggle, because 5 km is half of 10 km.

Part 5 · Weeks 30 to 36

Senses, light and signals

Structures inside and outside living things do jobs. Senses take in information, the brain decides and the body responds. You see because light reflects into your eyes. Patterns of light can carry a message, and two codes can be compared. Week 36 is the year.

Week 30Inside and Outside

Senses · sits beside: Structures that help living things survive (4-LS1-1)
The point

Every structure, inside or outside, does a job that helps a living thing survive, grow, behave or reproduce.

Answers and marking
Row aprotection
Row bmoving
Row creproduction
Row dgetting food or water
Row eprotection
Row fgetting food or water
How many for protection2
The structure for reproductiona flower’s bright petals
Watch for

Students who say petals are just for looking nice. Ask who they look nice for: the bees that carry pollen.

Challenge Zone

Any animal with three structures suited to cold: thick fur, small ears, wide feet for snow.

Week 31Parts With Jobs

Senses · sits beside: Structures that help living things survive (4-LS1-1)
The point

Inside structures have jobs too. Celery's tubes carry water up, and you can watch them do it.

Answers and marking
In the first 4 hours7 cm
The most between two checksbetween 8 and 24 hours
Watch for

Students who say the color climbed fastest at the end. It climbed the most centimeters in that gap, but the gap was 16 hours long; per hour it was slowest. That is worth a conversation.

Challenge Zone

Same celery, same water, same color, same time; only the leaves change.

Week 32Sense, Decide, Respond

Senses · sits beside: How animals use their senses (4-LS1-2)
The point

Senses take in information, the brain decides, and the body responds. It takes time, and practice shortens it.

Answers and marking
Sooner on every tryright
The best catch11 cm
Did practice helpyes
Watch for

Students who read the bigger number as better. A smaller number is a sooner catch.

Challenge Zone

Usually a little sooner or about the same. They used hearing instead of sight, and either way the brain still had to decide.

Week 33How You See

Senses · sits beside: Light, reflection and seeing (4-PS4-2)
The point

You see things because light reflects off them into your eyes. No light, no seeing.

Answers and marking
Named with no light holes0
Holes needed to name all five3
Watch for

Students who think eyes send out something that hits objects. The box shows the light has to get in first.

Challenge Zone

Arrows from lamp to book to eye; with the lamp off, no arrows, nothing seen.

Week 34A Pattern Carries a Message

Senses · sits beside: Patterns that carry information (4-PS4-3)
The point

A pattern can carry a message if both people know the code, and light can carry it across a room.

Answers and marking
The messageDECODE
BED in the codeLS / S / SS
Flashes to send CAB6
Watch for

Students who read the slashes as letters. They are the pauses.

Challenge Zone

Any code that both people can read the same way.

Week 35Two Codes Compared

Senses · sits beside: Patterns that carry information (4-PS4-3)
The point

Two codes can carry the same message, and choosing between them means choosing what matters more.

Answers and marking
DECODE in code X9 seconds
DECODE in code Y18 seconds
The code that meets the ruleY
Watch for

Students who think the faster code is always better. Ask which one they would trust with an emergency.

Challenge Zone

Any idea with a reason that really works. Two that do: keep code X's letters and make the pause between letters much longer (pauses are not counted, so it stays as fast as code X), or add a third kind of flash, such as a very long flash, so every letter fits in exactly 2 flashes (3 kinds in 2 places make 9 patterns, enough for 6 letters). Check the count with any fixed-length idea: 2 flashes of only short and long make 4 patterns, too few for the 6 letters.

Week 36Where Did It Go?

Review · sits beside: Energy moving from place to place (4-PS3-2)
The point

Energy was never used up. It moved, it changed form, and it carried information. That sentence is the year.

Answers and marking
Row asound
Row blight
Row cmotion
Row delectric current
Row eheat
Row flight
How many light rows2
The only heat rowe
Watch for

Each row names the way the energy arrives, and the word list keeps the counts fair. Accept a second form only with an explanation: the lamp in row b also warms the room a little.

Challenge Zone

Their own chain, as long as each link really passes energy to the next.

The topics

EnergySpeed and energy, and what happens to energy in a collision.
DesignA prototype, tested, changed one thing at a time, and tested again.
TransferEnergy moving as motion, sound, light, heat and electric current.
ConvertingEnergy changing form, on purpose, in a device students build.
SourcesWhere the energy people use comes from, and what each source costs.
LandscapesLayers, fossils, weathering, erosion and patterns on a map.
WavesEnergy carried by waves, measured by amplitude and wavelength.
EarthquakesWaves in the ground, staying safe, and structures that stand.
SensesStructures with jobs, senses and responses, seeing, and codes.
ReviewPulling a part into something a student could explain at home.

Materials and safety

Almost nothing needs buying. Most investigations use things a classroom or a kitchen already has: paper, cups, marbles, sugar cubes, celery, a flashlight. A few are worth gathering before the year starts: one AA battery, a small 1.5-volt flashlight bulb and two short wires (week 10), modeling clay and drinking straws (weeks 5, 6 and 27), food coloring (week 31), a pushpin and an empty toilet paper tube (week 12), and grass seed sown in a second pan of damp sand a week before week 19. The Try it box on page 1 lists each week’s materials so you can gather them in one look.

The safety notes that carry the year. Week 10 uses one small AA or AAA battery only: never a wall outlet, and never a wire straight from one end of a battery to the other, which gets hot. Weeks 34 and 35 use a flashlight: point it at a wall, never into anyone's eyes. Week 5 drops from table height only. Week 12's pinwheel pin is pushed in by an adult, and nobody holds a pinwheel near a fan without its guard. Marbles are picked up after week 3 so nobody slips. Week 24's rope stays low along the floor and away from faces, and week 27's shake table stays on the floor or in the middle of a table. Week 33 reminds students never to look straight at the sun.

There is no flame, no heating, and no chemical beyond what is in a kitchen anywhere in the book.