What Made That Happen? · Grade 3 science · 36 weeks
Answers, the point of each week, and the specific wrong turn each one produces.
Written for a teacher who is not a science specialist and does not need to become one.
Every table of results in the book is practice data, invented so the whole class
can answer the same questions, and the page says so every time. When your class does
the real investigation its numbers will differ. Ask which numbers are more
trustworthy, theirs or the book’s. The answer is theirs, because they watched it
happen.
No page asks a child which parent they look like, or what happened to their
family in a storm or a fire. Inherited traits belong to animals and plants, and
hazards belong to a made-up town. A child who has lived through one may want to talk
about it, and should be the one who decides to.
verify.py, which ships beside this file and runs on every build, checks
all 142 answers below: every number is recomputed from the practice data as
printed in the workbook, and every worded answer is checked against its expected
wording. It also checks that every table a page calls a fair test changes exactly one
thing.
A force is a push or a pull with a direction and a strength. Balanced forces change nothing; unbalanced forces start, stop, speed up, slow down or turn something. Friction, magnets and static. Week 5 is the fair test, which every later week leans on, and weeks 10 and 11 are the first design problems: criteria, constraints, and more than one solution compared honestly.
Week 1Push or Pull
Forces · sits beside: Forces and motion (3-PS2-1)
The point
A force is a push or a pull, and it always points somewhere. Drawing it as an arrow is the habit the whole first part is built on.
Answers and marking
Row a
push
Row b
pull
Row c
pull
Row d
push
Row e
pull
Row f
push
How many are pulls
3
The row that pulls up
b
Watch for
Students who call lifting a push because the arm goes up. Ask whether the backpack moves toward the person or away from them.
Challenge Zone
The plate side is for pushing, because there is nothing to grip; the handle side is for pulling. A good answer notices that the design tells your hand which force to use before you think about it.
Week 2Balanced
Forces · sits beside: Forces and motion (3-PS2-1)
The point
Something still is not something with no forces on it. It is something whose forces cancel.
Answers and marking
Game a
stays still
Game b
moves left
Game c
stays still
Game d
moves right
Game e
stays still
Games where the rope stays still
3
Game that moves most strongly
d
Watch for
Students who say the rope moves toward the smaller team because it is “losing.” Have two students actually pull, gently, three against one.
Challenge Zone
The rope moves right. Add one player to the left, or take one away from the right. Either works, and finding both is the point.
Week 3Unbalanced
Forces · sits beside: Forces and motion (3-PS2-1)
The point
When forces are unbalanced, the motion changes in one of five ways. Every change of motion has a force behind it.
Answers and marking
4 notches against 2 notches
42 cm
The biggest jump
2 and 3 notches
Between 75 cm and 90 cm
4 notches
Watch for
Students who think a ball keeps rolling “until it runs out of push.” It stops because something, the floor and the air, pushes back on it.
Challenge Zone
Friction between the ball and the grass, and the air pushing against it. Naming it before next week is a bonus; describing it is enough.
Week 4Rub and Slow
Forces · sits beside: Forces and motion (3-PS2-1)
The point
Friction is a force too, and it is the reason things slow down without anyone touching them.
Answers and marking
The most friction
towel
Tile against carpet
34 cm
Least to most friction
tile, paper, wood, carpet, towel
Watch for
Ordering by distance and calling the longest slide the most friction. A longer slide means LESS friction; say it the other way around until it sticks.
Challenge Zone
Your feet push backward on the ground to move you forward, and friction is what lets them. With almost none, the push just slides.
Week 5Change One Thing
Forces · sits beside: Forces and motion (3-PS2-1)
The point
A fair test changes one thing. It is the method for the rest of the year and the most useful idea in the book.
Answers and marking
Fair test of height
T1 and T3
Fair test of the floor
T1 and T4
Farther from the higher ramp
60 cm
Watch for
Students who pick T2 and T3 for height because their heights differ. Ask what else is different between them. Two things changed, so it tells you nothing.
Challenge Zone
Change the weight only: tape coins to the same car, same ramp, same floor, same start. Three things kept the same is the requirement; a good answer says “let go, do not push.”
Week 6The Swing Keeps Time
Forces · sits beside: Patterns of motion (3-PS2-2)
The point
A swinging weight repeats so steadily that you can count on it. That is a pattern, and a pattern is something you can predict with.
Answers and marking
As the string gets longer
fewer swings
20 cm against 100 cm
18
A 120 cm string
fewer than 15
Watch for
Students who count a swing as just “out.” One swing is out and back. Counts come out roughly double if they get this wrong, which is worth catching on the first try.
Challenge Zone
A heavier weight barely changes the count, which surprises almost everybody. A fair test keeps the string length the same and changes only the weight. The surprise is the lesson: test before you believe.
Week 7Predict the Roll
Forces · sits beside: Patterns of motion (3-PS2-2)
The point
A pattern is only useful if you use it to say what happens next, write that down first, and then check.
Answers and marking
Each extra book adds about
about 40 cm
Prediction for 5 books
about 200 cm
Height for a roll of about 100 cm
between 2 and 3 books
Watch for
Students who predict 5 books by doubling 2 books and adding something. Show them the differences column; the pattern is in the steps, not the totals.
Challenge Zone
No. The car might fly off a steep ramp, crash at the bottom, or roll off the end of the room. Patterns hold over the range you tested, and the farther you go past it the less you should trust them.
Week 8Without Touching
Forces · sits beside: Electric and magnetic forces (3-PS2-3)
The point
Magnets push and pull without touching, opposite poles attract and like poles repel, and the pull weakens with distance.
Answers and marking
Distance where it picked up none
5 cm
Fewer at 3 cm than at 1 cm
4
The farther away the magnet is
the fewer clips it picks up
Watch for
Students who think a magnet attracts all metal. It does not attract aluminum foil or most coins. Let them find that out with a test.
Challenge Zone
A magnet pulls through a hand and through a book. Through a cookie sheet it can stick to, it pulls much less, because it pulls on the sheet instead. Check the sheet first: if the magnet does not stick to it, it is probably aluminum and the clip will be pulled straight through, which is a different test. A good plan keeps the distance the same and changes only the material in between.
Week 9The Balloon Trick
Forces · sits beside: Electric and magnetic forces (3-PS2-3)
The point
Rubbing can build up a charge that pulls light things without touching, and there is a limit to how much rubbing helps.
Answers and marking
10 rubs against 5 rubs
4
Fewest rubs that lifted the most
20 rubs
Watch for
Students who answer 25, because that is where the table ends. 20 rubs and 25 rubs lifted the same number; the question asks for the fewest.
Challenge Zone
A magnet pulls iron and steel and keeps pulling; a rubbed balloon pulls light things like paper and hair, and its pull fades over time. Either difference is a complete answer.
Week 10A Job for a Magnet
Forces · sits beside: Solving a problem with magnets (3-PS2-4)
The point
Criteria say what a solution must do; constraints say what you may use. Writing both first turns an argument into a test.
Answers and marking
Meets every criterion and constraint
A
Stayed shut best but broke a constraint
B
Why B failed
used two magnets
Why C failed
does not open with one hand
Why D failed
stayed shut only 6 times
Watch for
Students who pick B because it stayed shut every time. It used two magnets. A solution that breaks a rule is not a winner, however well it works.
Challenge Zone
Move the clip closer, use a bigger clip, or add a second clip. Any change is fine if the test is the same 10 bumps.
There is more than one solution, and comparing them fairly means the same test for each, against the same rules.
Answers and marking
Meets both rules
folded like a fan
Fan against flat
35
Watch for
Students who choose the tubes because they look strongest. They used two sheets. Strong is not the same as allowed.
Challenge Zone
Many shapes beat the fan: a deeper fold, a fan with its edges taped. What matters is the prediction written down before the test.
Week 12What Made It Move?
Review · sits beside: Forces and motion (3-PS2-1)
The point
Every change in motion had a cause, and Part 1 gave students the words and the method to find it.
Answers and marking
The drawn box moves
right
A change that balances the drawn box
add a push of 4 pointing left, or make the 6 into a 2
Box a
stays still
Box b
right
Box c
left
Box d
stays still
Box e
left
How many stay still
2
The two that move left
c and e
Moving box closest to balanced
c
Watch for
Students who say a box pushed from the left moves left. Have one student push a book from its left side and watch where it goes.
Challenge Zone
On the left side, a push of 5 pointing right: then 6 and 6 balance. Adding a push on the right side can only make it worse, and a student who says so has understood the whole of Part 1.
Part 2 · Weeks 13 to 21
Life cycles for survival
Every kind of living thing has a life cycle with the same four stages; metamorphosis rebuilds a body between them. Young inherit traits from their parents and always vary. A small difference can be an advantage, and living in a group can help a kind of animal survive.
Week 13Born, Grow, Make More
Life Cycles · sits beside: Life cycles (3-LS1-1)
The point
Every kind of living thing has a life cycle with the same four stages, in the same order, and the young begin it again. That is why it is drawn as a circle.
Answers and marking
Saw all four stages
bean plant
How many had young
3
Watch for
Students who conclude the goldfish cannot reproduce. A stage the class did not see is not a stage the animal lacks.
Challenge Zone
Any animal, four stages, a picture for each. Accept “born” or “hatched” for the first stage.
Week 14The Frog and the Bean
Life Cycles · sits beside: Life cycles (3-LS1-1)
The point
Two life cycles with the same stages and completely different stories.
Answers and marking
Growth from week 2 to week 7
19 cm
The biggest week of growth
weeks 4 and 5
The stage after flowering
seed pod
Watch for
Subtracting week 1 from week 7 for the first question. The question starts at week 2. For the last question, also accept an answer that says the plant makes seeds or has young: that is the same stage in the four-stage words of week 13.
Challenge Zone
Frog young hatch in water and look nothing like the adult; bean young are seeds that look nothing like the plant either. Both begin small and grow. Any two differences and one sameness is a full answer.
Week 15A Whole New Body
Life Cycles · sits beside: Life cycles (3-LS1-1)
The point
Metamorphosis rebuilds a body between stages. A caterpillar and a butterfly are the same animal.
Answers and marking
Caterpillar A, days in all
17
Caterpillar B, days in all
17
Caterpillar C, days in all
17
Caterpillar D, days in all
19
Caterpillar E, days in all
18
Took the longest
D
How many took exactly 17 days
3
Watch for
Students who think a chrysalis is a case the caterpillar builds around itself. It is the pupa's own hardened skin. Moths spin cocoons; butterflies do not. It is not worth a long fight, but the book uses the right word.
Challenge Zone
Variation: the caterpillars differ a little, as every living thing does. Some ate more, some were warmer. Any reasonable cause is fine; this is week 17 arriving early.
Week 16Like Their Parents
Traits · sits beside: Inherited traits (3-LS3-1)
The point
Young inherit traits from both parents, and they do not all inherit the same ones.
Answers and marking
Mother's ears
3
Father's fur and father's ears
Puppy 2
Exactly like the mother
yes, 2
Watch for
Students who think a puppy must be a mix, with brown-and-black fur. Some traits blend, many do not, and the table is the evidence.
Challenge Zone
Yes. Both parents can carry a trait they do not show and pass it on. The point is not the mechanism, which comes much later, but that the parents' own looks do not tell the whole story.
Week 17Not Exactly Alike
Traits · sits beside: Variation in traits (3-LS3-1)
The point
Living things of the same kind always vary. Measure enough of them and a line plot shows the shape of the variation.
Answers and marking
The most common length
4 inches
Longest against shortest
2½ inches
Longer than 4 inches
4
Watch for
Counting the pod at exactly 4 inches as longer than 4. Longer than means strictly more.
Challenge Zone
The same shape, a hump in the middle, but smoother. Any drawing with most pods in the middle and a few at each end is right.
Week 18A Little Different Helps
Traits · sits beside: Variation and survival (3-LS4-2)
The point
A small difference can be an advantage, and the animals with the advantage are the ones that survive to have young.
Answers and marking
Survived better
newspaper moths
White moths found
38
Newspaper moths found
14
White against newspaper
24
Watch for
Students who say white survived better because more were found. Found means eaten. Fewer found means more survived.
Challenge Zone
On white paper the white moths hide and the newspaper ones show. The advantage belongs to the match between the animal and its background, not to the color itself.
Week 19Safety in Numbers
Groups · sits beside: Groups help animals survive (3-LS2-1)
The point
A group helps its members survive, and it costs them something too.
Answers and marking
Noticed sooner in every visit
the flock
The quickest time
2 seconds
The biggest difference
visit 4
Watch for
Reading a bigger number as better. Here a smaller number of seconds is quicker.
Challenge Zone
Where food is scarce and spread out, a lone bird does not have to share. Any place where sharing costs more than the extra eyes are worth.
Week 20Jobs in the Group
Groups · sits beside: Groups help animals survive (3-LS2-1)
The point
In a colony every member has a job, and the colony survives because the jobs are shared.
Answers and marking
Ants counted in all
52
Food carriers against guards
21
Watch for
Bars drawn to the nearest line instead of the number. 26 is just above 25 and 9 is almost at 10; a bar that sits on 25 and one that sits on 10 is a scale-reading slip.
Challenge Zone
Honey bees make honey, make wax, fan their wings to cool the hive, and dance to show other bees where food is. Any one, found and written down.
Week 21Why Make More?
Review · sits beside: Life cycles (3-LS1-1)
The point
Life cycles, traits and groups all answer the same question: how a kind of living thing keeps going.
Answers and marking
How many go through metamorphosis
3
The plant
bean
Watch for
Calling a chick's hatching metamorphosis. It hatches already shaped like a chicken.
Challenge Zone
Five sentences, one per idea. Mark the five ideas, not the writing.
Part 3 · Weeks 22 to 29
Surviving in different environments
A trait can be caused by the environment rather than by parents. A habitat suits some living things and not others, and a changed habitat changes who survives. Fossils are evidence of living things and of places that are gone. The part ends by judging a fix for a changed environment against rules written down first.
Week 22Grown, Not Born
Environments · sits beside: Environment and traits (3-LS3-2)
The point
The environment can cause a trait. Same seeds, different light, very different plants.
Answers and marking
Grew taller
dark cupboard
Tallest dark against tallest sunny
5 cm
Watch for
Students who “correct” the table because plants need light so the sunny ones must be taller. Plants in the dark really do grow tall and pale while they search for light. Let them grow it and see.
Challenge Zone
Light was meant to change; the packet, the water and the soil stayed the same. But a sunny window is warmer than a dark cupboard, so temperature probably changed too. A student who notices that has understood fair tests better than the page, and should be told so. Putting both cups by the window and covering one with a box would be fairer.
Week 23Parent or Place?
Environments · sits beside: Environment and traits (3-LS3-2)
The point
A trait can come from parents, from the place, or from both, and saying “both” is often the right answer.
Answers and marking
Row a
parents
Row b
place
Row c
parents
Row d
place, or both
Row e
parents
Row f
place, or both
How many come from the parents only
3
Watch for
Students who put the dog's trick under parents because the dog is smart. Being able to learn is inherited; the trick itself was taught.
Challenge Zone
Height in a person or a tree is the classic: parents set a range, food and light decide where in it. Any trait with both parts named.
Week 24Who Lives Here?
Environments · sits beside: Survival in a habitat (3-LS4-3)
The point
A habitat gives food, water, shelter and space, so where an animal is found is evidence of what it needs.
Answers and marking
Most animals in all
under a log
Found in all three places
beetles
Found in only one place
frogs and grasshoppers
Watch for
Students who answer the dry field because it had the most grasshoppers. The question is the total for each place.
Challenge Zone
Damp, dark, cool and food: rotting wood. Any two that a worm needs.
Week 25When the Place Changes
Environments · sits beside: Survival in a changing habitat (3-LS4-3)
The point
When a habitat changes, some living things survive well, some less well, and some not at all.
Answers and marking
First week with no frogs
week 5
Water drop from week 1 to week 4
28 cm
The biggest drop in frogs
weeks 3 and 4
Watch for
Reading week 4 for the first zero because the frog count was small. Small is not zero.
Challenge Zone
Beetles, worms or mosquitoes in damp mud; anything that does not need deep water. The good answer says what the mud gives it.
Week 26Stone Clues
Environments · sits beside: Fossils as evidence (3-LS4-1)
The point
Fossils are evidence of living things and of the places they lived, and lower layers are usually older.
Answers and marking
The oldest layer
D, with fern leaves
The two water layers
B and C
The top two layers
wet first, then dry
Watch for
Students who say the top layer is oldest because it was found first. Ask which layer had to be there before the others could be put on top.
Challenge Zone
Bottom to top: forest, lake, desert, town. The order is the whole answer; the fossils are a bonus.
Week 27A Fish on a Mountain
Environments · sits beside: Fossils as evidence (3-LS4-1)
The point
A sea fossil on a mountain means the land rose, not that the fish climbed. Fossils describe environments that are gone.
Answers and marking
Once under the sea
A and C
Most likely a forest
B
Watch for
Students who put D under the sea because crocodiles swim. Crocodiles and palms together mean a warm swamp on land. It is worth saying that “most likely” is an honest answer.
Challenge Zone
One fossil can be moved by a bird, a flood or a person; many fossils of many kinds in one layer are hard to explain any other way.
Week 28A Problem When Things Change
Environments · sits beside: Solutions to a changed environment (3-LS4-4)
The point
A solution is a claim, and the way to judge a claim is to count before and after.
Answers and marking
Total before
12
Total after
42
More crossings after
30
Every week after better than every week before
yes
Watch for
Comparing only week 1 to week 1. The question is about the totals.
Challenge Zone
Count for longer, at the same time of year, in the same way, and if possible on a nearby road with no tunnel as a comparison.
Week 29Judge the Fix
Environments · sits beside: Solutions to a changed environment (3-LS4-4)
The point
A fix is judged against rules written down first, and a fix that breaks either rule is out.
Answers and marking
Meets both rules
plant grass on the banks
Clear enough but too costly
pile rocks along the edge
Watch for
Students who choose the rocks because the score is fine. It costs 60 dollars a meter; the limit is less than 50.
Challenge Zone
Any reasoned note. A strong one says grass is the long-term fix and asks whether something cheap could hold the bank while it grows.
Part 4 · Weeks 30 to 36
Weather and what it does
Weather measured and written into tables and graphs, climate as the pattern weather makes over years, climates far away, and designing against a weather hazard. Week 36 is the year in one question.
Week 30Weather in a Table
Weather · sits beside: Weather data in tables and graphs (3-ESS2-1)
The point
Weather is measured, and a table of measurements shows what is usual and what is not.
Answers and marking
The highest high
70°
The lowest high
58°
The difference
12°
Rainy days
4
Rainy days below 62°
3
Watch for
Reading only the first week. The table has two weeks side by side.
Challenge Zone
In this table the rainy days were cooler. Two weeks is not enough to be sure; any answer that says why is right.
Week 31A Season in a Graph
Weather · sits beside: Weather data in tables and graphs (3-ESS2-1)
The point
A bar graph of a season is how weather becomes a pattern you can see.
Answers and marking
Dec
6
Jan
8
Feb
7
Mar
5
The most rainy days
Jan
Rainy days in all
26
January against March
3
Watch for
Reading a bar between two lines as the lower line. February is 7, not 6.
Challenge Zone
Their own graph, their own scale. Check that the scale starts at 0 and goes up evenly.
Week 32Climate Is the Pattern
Weather · sits beside: Climates of different regions (3-ESS2-2)
The point
Weather is one day; climate is the pattern over many years.
Answers and marking
Town A, summer against winter
35°
Town B, summer against winter
10°
The bigger change
Town A
The two summer highs
2°
Watch for
Students who think Town B has the bigger change because its numbers are bigger. They are bigger in every season, but they hardly move.
Challenge Zone
One snowy day is weather. Climate is about many years, so one day cannot tell you it is changing.
Week 33Climates Far Away
Weather · sits beside: Climates of different regions (3-ESS2-2)
The point
Telling climates apart needs two clues, rain and temperature, because a polar place can be as dry as a desert.
Answers and marking
Place P
hot desert
Place Q
rainforest
Place R
polar, a cold desert
Place S
in between
Most likely a hot desert
P
Less than 10 inches
P and R
Most likely a rainforest
Q
Watch for
Calling R a hot desert from the rain alone. It is dry, but it is freezing: a polar place, which some scientists call a cold desert.
Challenge Zone
A camel can go a long time without water; a polar bear has thick fur and a thick layer of fat. Each trait suits one climate and would be a problem in the other.
Week 34When Weather Is Dangerous
Weather · sits beside: Reducing the impact of weather hazards (3-ESS3-1)
The point
A hazard cannot be stopped, but the harm it does can be reduced, and that is a design problem.
Answers and marking
Higher than 12 feet
day 4
The most rain
day 3
Watch for
Including day 5 at 12 feet. Higher than 12 means more than 12.
Challenge Zone
Any three clear steps. A child who has been through a real hazard may know more than the page; let them lead if they choose to.
Week 35Design Against the Weather
Weather · sits beside: Reducing the impact of weather hazards (3-ESS3-1)
The point
Criteria and constraints again, this time against a real hazard students can feel on a sunny day.
Answers and marking
The two designs that meet both
cloth sail and vine-covered frame
Coolest of those two
cloth sail
Cloth sail against no shade
26°
Watch for
Including the umbrella because it is under 100 degrees. It costs 45 dollars; the limit is less than 40.
Challenge Zone
A note with one number from the table as evidence. That is the whole requirement, and it is a high one for Grade 3.
Week 36What Made That Happen?
Review · sits beside: Planning a fair test (3-5-ETS1-3)
The point
Every change had a cause, and a fair test is how you find it. That method is the year.
Answers and marking
Row a
friction
Row b
environment
Row c
magnet
Row d
inherited
Row e
environment
Row f
ramp height
How many caused by the environment
2
Watch for
The word list on the page keeps the count from depending on wording. Row a is friction, not environment: the page defines environment as what is around a living thing, and a ball is not one.
Challenge Zone
One design from the year, one thing changed (a second clip on the latch, a deeper fold in the bridge, a lighter cloth on the shade), the rest kept the same, and a failure point named before the test, such as the latch staying shut fewer than 8 times out of 10. Mark the plan, not the design.
The topics
ForcesPushes and pulls, their direction and strength, and the fair test that finds out which one caused a change.
Life CyclesBegins, grows, has young, dies, and the young begin again.
TraitsWhat young inherit from parents, how much they vary, and when a difference is an advantage.
GroupsLiving together helps some animals survive, and it costs them too.
EnvironmentsHabitats, what happens when they change, and the fossils that record places that are gone.
WeatherMeasured weather, climate as its pattern, and designing against a hazard.
ReviewPulling a part into something a student could explain at home.
Materials and safety
Nothing needs buying. Almost every
investigation uses things a classroom or a kitchen already has: paper, cups, string, books,
a ruler, dry beans, a balloon, a magnet. A few go outside (leaves in week 17, an ant trail
in week 20, a log in week 24, a sunny spot and a playground slide in week 35), and a thermometer or a magnifying glass helps if you have
one. The Try it box on page 1 lists each week’s materials so you can gather
them in one look.
The safety lines the book prints, in one
place. Week 2: pull gently and never let go suddenly. Weeks 8 and 10: small magnets
never go in anyone’s mouth; keep them away from younger children. Week 9: check for
latex allergies, and never put a balloon or a piece of a popped one in a mouth. Weeks 14
and 22: dry beans and bean seeds are for growing, not eating (some are harmful raw, and
packet seeds may be coated); wash hands after handling soil and seeds. Week 17: pick leaves
only from a plant an adult has checked, and wash hands afterward. Week 20: watch ants
without touching them, because some sting. Week 24: an adult rolls the log or rock toward
themselves; students never reach under one, and everything goes back the way it was found.
Week 35: students do not touch metal that has been in the sun; use a thermometer or have
an adult check. Only the two pieces of paper in week 35 are for feeling.
There is no flame, no heating, and no chemical beyond
what is in a kitchen anywhere in the book.